Home › News › Hit or hide? A puzzle about one roll of 5

Hit or hide? A puzzle about one roll of 5

Published · By TG, the site operator

Today's note is a puzzle from this board's rules. The answer comes from a program that plays out every roll of the rest of the game, with the best move for both colours, under the rules in the site's code: a six to come out, another roll after a six, the third six in a row passing the turn, no extra roll for a capture. Its moves matched the site's rules code in all 35,089,200 test cases, and 800,000 games per move played through that code agreed with its figures.

The position

Late in a game each side has two tokens home and two still running. Squares are counted from each colour's entry square, where its tokens leave the yard. Violet's entry square lies 26 squares round the loop from Red's.

36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47

R V . * . V R . . . . *

R is a red token, V a violet one and * a safe square, numbered from Red's entry square. You roll a 5. You can hit: the back token goes from 36 to 41 and sends the violet token there back to the yard. Or you can hide: the front token goes from 42 to the safe square on 47. Which move wins more often?

Show the answer

Hide. With best play from here, Red wins 82.3% of games after the move to the safe square, and 71.7% after the hit.

After the hit your tokens stand on 41 and 42, four and five squares in front of Violet's other token, and the capture earns no extra roll to move them on. With best play, Violet's next turn costs you 16.5 squares of progress on average. After the hide, no violet token can reach your tokens: the front one is on a safe square, and no violet token is left behind the back one. That back token still has both violet tokens in front of it, one and five squares away, and one roll moves only one of them. With best play you then hit one on your next turn 22.3% of the time, against 4.0% after the capture.

Hitting is usually right

This position is an exception. The program checked all 21,439 positions of the same kind: two tokens left on each side, a roll of 1 to 5, and a choice between a hit and taking a token with a violet token up to six squares behind it to a safe square or into the home column. Hitting was better in 20,519 of them (95.7%). In 755 of the 920 exceptions, the hit left a red token up to six squares in front of a violet token, as it does here.

Against the computer

On Normal and Hard, the site's computer takes a hit whenever one is on offer, unless it can bring a token home instead: its move scoring gives every capture a large bonus. Given this roll it would hit, so here you can play better than it does. Try a game against Hard on the game page; the guide explains safe squares and captures.

Sources

Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.

All ludo news · Play ludo now